Keeping it real
I have to confess, that when eating my “save-money-while-unemployed” salad and tuna sandwiches, I’ve been tuning in to Oprah and The View. On The View the other week, they were getting the low-down on the Golden Globes from Mario Cantone, a camp comedian and performer. Watching his commentary, I found myself thinking, ‘oy vey, how gay he is!’ I immediately sat up straight. I wondered whether my comment was really a criticism of him – conscious or not. At some level, I felt that I was being critical when I blurted it out.
It reminded me of growing up, when you hear peers/friends describe some guy as “so gay”. When I heard this, I used to think they were implying that these guys were putting on the ‘gayness’ and being fake – camping it up. Not only was there the negative of being accused of being gay, but there was the implication these guys were not being real or authentic. So added to the long list of negatives associated with gay men, there is also an implication that their more feminine behaviour is fake.
This implication is not something, though, which is confined to the world of judgmental teenagers. In adulthood, I’ve had several friends ask me about a good (gay) friend who is quite camp. The questions have often been along the lines of “is he really that camp, or is he putting it on”? Though slightly irritated, I usually respond calmly that this particular friend was camp when he was growing up, and that his behaviour was very natural and unconscious.
I’ve often felt bothered by being asked this question about him, but I haven’t known why. I knew that these friends weren’t homophobic – they treated their gay friends like me the same as their straight ones. I realised later that what bothered me was the fact that when people questioned whether my friend was putting on his campness, there were in fact comparing him with the typical, heterosexual guys they knew. They assumed that the typical straight-guy demeanour, stripped of any softness, expressiveness or femininity, is real, and therefore the camp guy must be hiding this authentic self behind a flamboyant facade. Mr hetero straighty-one-eighty is presumed to be authentic, while guys who show too much expressiveness, are assumed to be putting 'it' on. And this, I’ve realised, is what really gets to me.
In reality, I think that the opposite is more likely to be true. The pressure is huge among young, straight guys not to appear gay. (Just read some bullying statistics for guys who are perceived to bee too feminine, to see one of the dangerous effects that can result from this fallacious view of masculinity.) So, to prove their manhood, young straight guys often display hyper-masculine behaviours, banishing any feminine characteristics they may have had since boyhood - as natural as these may be. All you have to do, though, to see that this hyper-masculine behaviour is put on, is to pop into a pub and see some of these guys after they’ve had a few beers. There you’ll see the camp, silly, and genuinely touchy-feely sides – so often hidden – come out (sorry, but the pun was too tempting )
To me, if anyone is likely to putting it on, it’s these guys, who feel the need to demonstrate in front of their mates that they are 100% hetero. Maybe we should stop assuming that just because there are a larger number of straight guys who behave blokishly, than guys who are camp, that blokey behaviour is authentic. Authenticity is something much more than conforming to majority behaviour. If we bare this in mind, then we could all truly keep it real ourselves, as well as allow others to do so too.